Controlling Paris

Armed Forces and Counter-Revolution, 1789-1848

324 pages

3 maps

February, 2014

ISBN: 9781479881154

$55

Cloth

Also available in

Subjects:

HistoryMilitary History

Part of the Warfare and Culture series

Author

Jonathan M. House is William A. Stofft Professor of Military History at the U.S. Army Command & General Staff College. His previous books include Combined Arms Warfare in the 20th Century; A Military History of the Cold War, 1944-1962; and, with David M. Glantz, When Titans Clashed: How the Red Army Stopped Hitler.  

All books by Jonathan M. House

When not at war, armies are often used to control civil disorders, especially in eras of rapid social change and unrest. But in nineteenth century Europe, without the technological advances of modern armies and police forces, an army’s only advantages were discipline and organization—and in the face of popular opposition to the regime in power, both could rapidly deteriorate. Such was the case in France after the Napoleonic Wars, where a cumulative recent history of failure weakened an already fragile army’s ability to keep the peace.
 
After the February 1848 overthrow of the last king of France, the new republican government proved remarkably resilient, retaining power while pursuing moderate social policies despite the concerted efforts of a variety of radical and socialist groups. These efforts took numerous forms, ranging from demonstrations to attempted coups to full-scale urban combat, and culminated in the crisis of the June Days. At stake was the future of French government and the social and economic policy of France at large.
 
In Controlling Paris, Jonathan M. House offers us a study of revolution from the viewpoint of the government rather than the revolutionary. It is not focused on military tactics so much as on the broader issues involved in controlling civil disorders: relations between the government and its military leaders, causes and social issues of public disorder, political loyalty of troops in crisis, and excessive use of force to control civil disorders. Yet somehow, despite all these disadvantages, the French police and armed forces prevented regime change far more often than they failed to do so.
 

Reviews

  • “The first, most striking impression upon reading Controlling Paris is that when seen from the perspective of those confronting the popular uprisings, the rebellion seems to have had extraordinary resources: secrecy and discipline of secret societies, combined with the amorphous and unpredictable power of the masses calling for social and economic change provided an advantage to the people.”

    The Journal of Modern History

  • “[…] House has crafted a valuable addition to the history and literature of Paris and the French Revolution of 1848.”

    European History Quarterly

  • "Most historians who have written about revolutionary movements in France have sympathized with the insurgents and told their stories from the point of view of the barricades. For this reason, House's decision to write a history of the Revolution of February-June 1848 from the vantage point of the forces of order is particularly striking . . . . Highly recommended."

    —, Choice

  • “This thought-provoking study engages with a hidden dimension of the great Parisian revolutionary upheavals of the first half of the nineteenth century—the extent to which insurgent successes and failures were shaped by the fluctuating strength of their opponents, the official forces of order. . . . [I]t does effectively demonstrate that revolutionary situations are, above all, confrontations of force, and that in such situations, the circumstances and motivations of both sides need to be taken into account in explaining their outcomes.”

    Journal of Interdisciplinary History

  • "In France between July 1789 and June 1848, power all too often grew out of the barrel of a gun. Crucial in holding or seizing power was control of the capital city, Paris. In this pioneering and thoroughly researched book, Jonathan M. House shows for the first time the problems on both sides of the barricades, as individuals grappled with the dilemmas of using or not using deadly force. He has made a major contribution to our understanding of the instability and violence that were part of France’s experience for over half a century of revolutions."

    —Robert Tombs, University of Cambridge

  • "Jonathan House’s detailed and balanced history provides us with a much-needed and most valuable understanding of the part played by military force in the drama of Parisian resistance and revolution 1815-1848. One is struck by what a surprisingly even fight it was when armed crowds confronted armed forces. It is fair to say that the army lost the Revolution of 1830 and the February phase of the Revolution of 1848; moreover, the deadly June days were a more near run thing than one would imagine. This is not a history of righteousness vs. repression, or of order vs. chaos, but of the way things happened."

    —John A. Lynn II, Professor Emeritus of History, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

  • "An important work on civil-military relations that is topical for today."

    —Jeremy Black, University of Exeter